Attentive is an SMS-first platform that also sends email; Klaviyo is an email-first ecommerce platform that also sends SMS. Attentive fits brands that treat SMS as a major channel and want hands-on support; Klaviyo fits brands whose revenue runs through email. Brands that run both pay two vendors for the same customers, and Relvino replaces both with one engine.
Most comparisons of these two treat it as a single-winner question. For a brand already paying both, the more useful question is what the two-tool setup costs. We build the single-engine alternative, so the reframe at the end is ours; the head-to-head is fair to each.
The rule of thumb the market uses: Attentive when SMS is a real revenue channel you want hands-on support for, Klaviyo when email is the centre of gravity and SMS is a secondary channel. Klaviyo’s own comparison page makes the case for consolidating email and SMS onto Klaviyo instead of adding Attentive.
Running both is a legitimate choice, and it carries four costs worth naming before you renew.
Klaviyo and Attentive both organize automation as flows or journeys, and both now add AI that helps build them: Klaviyo’s Composer agent can create campaigns and flows, and Attentive’s AI Journeys triggers personalized welcome and abandonment messages. So a brand running both is running the same kind of program twice, in two places, at two prices, on top of a large waste: a $20M brand loses roughly $2M a year sending the wrong message to the wrong customer ($20M GMV × ~10–12% email-attributable revenue × ~80% waste; sources: Bloomreach and Mailchimp benchmarks, 2024–2025).
Relvino, the Klaviyo alternative we build, runs Observe → Decide → Act across channels rather than within one. It reads live shopper signals, decides the offer, timing, and channel for each individual in ~80ms, and executes across email, SMS and pop-ups from one system. Channel choice becomes an output of the model instead of a rule you maintain in two tools. You set guardrails - margin floors, channels, quiet hours, brand voice - and 100% of flows run autonomously inside them. SMS still runs on express written opt-in, because consent is a legal requirement, not an optimization.
The engine is a Large Retail Model trained on 7M+ data points across 10,000+ retailers and 1.78M shoppers, so it arrives already knowing what works in your category rather than learning only from your own store. Brands replacing their stack see 2–6× ROI in 30 days, with 6× year-over-year revenue uplift versus Attentive and up to 4× versus Klaviyo, and 80% less spam.
If you are staying with flows and SMS is a serious channel you want hands-on support for, Attentive earns its price. If email drives most of your revenue, consolidating SMS onto Klaviyo saves a second vendor and a second bill. But if you are a $20–100M GMV brand already paying two platforms to run the same paradigm twice, the question worth asking at renewal is whether any human should be deciding channel and timing shopper by shopper. See the wider field in Klaviyo competitors, the head-to-head in Klaviyo vs Relvino and its side-by-side comparison, the GearIT case study: 2X flow revenue delivered in 12 days, or pricing.
Generally yes, if SMS is a primary revenue channel. Attentive was built for SMS first, and its own pages lead with two-tap sign-up, SMS compliance safeguards such as quiet hours and known-litigator suppression, and hands-on support. Klaviyo SMS is the better choice when your SMS program is smaller and you would rather keep one platform, one profile, and one bill.
Postscript and Emotive compete directly on SMS-first ecommerce messaging, and Klaviyo competes for the same budget by bundling SMS into its email platform. At the enterprise end, Braze and Iterable orchestrate SMS as one channel among many. Relvino competes by removing the separate SMS program entirely and deciding channel per shopper inside one engine.
Yes. Attentive builds and documents the integration in its own help center, and a brand installs it from Attentive’s Marketplace with a Klaviyo private API key. It sends email subscribers captured through Attentive sign-up units into Klaviyo with profile properties, brings Klaviyo segments into Attentive, and keeps email opt-outs aligned: in real time from Attentive to Klaviyo, and at least every eight hours the other way. Each tool keeps its own sending: Attentive its texts (and its own email, if the brand buys it), Klaviyo its email, so a brand running both still pays two vendors, and Klaviyo also sends SMS itself on the same profile.
Only if SMS is large enough to justify a dedicated platform and a second bill. Many brands run both out of sequence rather than strategy - email first, then SMS bolted on. Before renewing both, price consolidating onto one, and count the flows that currently exist twice. Running the same kind of program in two tools is a cost worth pricing before either renewal.
On the flow-based side, Omnisend, Mailchimp, Brevo, Attentive, Postscript, Drip, and HubSpot. The newer category is autonomous decisioning, where Relvino replaces the flow and campaign stack outright rather than competing feature for feature. See the full Klaviyo competitor landscape.
Yes. Klaviyo now describes itself as an agent-first B2C CRM, with email, SMS, mobile push and WhatsApp on one customer profile and a marketing agent, Composer, that can create campaigns and flows. The open question for a brand running it beside Attentive is which system picks the channel for each shopper; Relvino makes that call per shopper in ~80ms, inside one engine.
Yes, provided consent is real. Automation changes who composes the message, not the legal basis for sending it: you still need express written opt-in, clear disclosure at sign-up, working opt-out handling, and quiet-hours respect. Relvino treats those as guardrails the system cannot send outside of, rather than as rules a marketer remembers to configure.
About 30 minutes for the technical migration: connect DNS, install the Shopify app, connect SMS, and your historical data ingests automatically. Subscriber consent records come across so opt-in status is preserved, and existing flows are switched off rather than rebuilt. After that, pause your incumbents rather than cancelling them. The path starts with a free 7-day teardown of your current program, walked through on a call, then a monthly or annual plan.
Connect email and SMS, install the Shopify app, and share your brand assets and any CRM data. Relvino reads your brand voice from your website, and you set your guardrails. Brands that switch pay 90 to 95% of their old Klaviyo or Attentive bill.
It works inside your global brand guardrails and each campaign’s or flow’s own guardrails. A non-AI QA layer scores every AI output before anything is sent, across email, SMS and pop-ups.
Privately, on Relvino’s own infrastructure. Each brand’s data stays separate; the cross-retail model learns from aggregated patterns, never another brand’s customers. Relvino is working toward SOC 2, targeted for mid-November 2026.